Here are some details which contradict or call into question the “official” version on Armita:
- On Oct. 5 The Guardian reported that an eyewitness described how a hijab enforcer immediately confronted Armita when she entered the train. "The chador-clad woman screamed at her asking her why was she not covered. Armita then told her ‘Do I ask you to remove your headscarf? Why are you asking me to wear one?’ Their argument then turned violent. The hijab enforcer started physically attacking Armita and … violently pushed her.”
- Multiple cameras are constantly recording inside the metro trains, but no footage has been released from inside the train.
- The Coordinating Council of Teacher's Organizations reported that the heads of security from both the Ministry of Education and the General Directorate of Education in Tehran visited Armita's school. They threatened teachers not to share any news or photos of Armita on social media and threatened Armita’s classmates against sharing any information about her condition. Armita's friends who were with her on the day of the incident are facing immense pressure to deny any involvement or knowledge of what transpired.
- A journalist who went to Fajr Hospital to find information was detained for 24 hours.Streets around Fajr Hospital are heavily controlled by police and military, and all access to the hospital is blocked.
- Human Rights group Hengaw reported that security forces confiscated cell phones from all members of Armita’s family, none of whom has been allowed to see her in the hospital as of this writing.
- State TV ran a tape of her parents –under military and police pressure inside Fajr—saying that they were shown the video and saw no evidence on video she was assaulted, but even under the fear for their whole family and their daughter they did not go beyond saying what the officials told them to say.
Although, as in Mahsa Jina Amini’s case, the truth of exactly what happened and exactly who struck the blow to the head of this young woman may continue to be suppressed, there is no doubt that it is the Islamic Republic of Iran, its compulsory hijab law and its violent enforcement that has created the societal atmosphere for vicious official and unofficial assaults on hijabless women.
Far from backing off from enforcing the compulsory hijab law, the IRI has doubled down on it in recent months. On September 20, 2023, just four days after the anniversary of Jina’s death, Iran’s parliament approved the draconian “Hijab and Chastity Law”, under which women face up to 10 years in prison if they continue to defy the country’s mandatory hijab rules and to identify those who “promote nudity [or] indecency” or “mock” the rules in a virtual or non-virtual space.[i]
[i] “Iran approves stricter hijab bill targeting those who ‘mock’ dress code”, The Guardian, September 20, 2023.